Part 1 of 2. Most 'agencies' aren't. Here's how to spot a real one, and the first four signs that it's actually good.
Only a small fraction of self-described design ‘agencies’ are real ones: many are freelancers speaking as ‘we’ (pseudo-agencies) or middlemen who quietly outsource your project (fake agencies). A real agency has a dedicated team, a verifiable history, technical infrastructure and a physical location. Use a checklist of positive signs; if an agency meets fewer than about half, it’s probably not the right fit regardless of price. Part 1 covers the first four signs: is it a real company, does it have solid structure, is it reliable, and does it have a portfolio.
Key takeaways
- Anyone with design software can claim to be an 'agency'; real ones are a small minority.
- Pseudo-agency = a freelancer posing as a team; fake agency = a middleman outsourcing your work.
- A real agency has a team, verifiable history, infrastructure and a physical location.
- Judge against a checklist; under ~50% of the signs means probably not the right fit.
- Part 1's four signs: real company, solid structure, reliability, and a portfolio.
Three kinds of 'agency'
| Type | What it really is | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Pseudo-agency | A single freelancer or a couple of colleagues speaking in the plural (‘we’). Often short-lived, since pay disputes between coders, designers, SEOs and sales break them up. | Overstated |
| Fake agency | Someone with marketing/network skills who claims to own a studio but secretly outsources the work, taking a large cut and often lacking real understanding. Some even hire pseudo-agencies (a ‘double deception’). | Deceptive |
| Real agency | Dedicated teams, a solid and verifiable history, technical infrastructure and a physical location. Not a guarantee of quality, but far better odds. | Legit |
Signs 1-4 of a good agency
The remaining six signs continue in Part 2. See also the companion checklist, 5 tips to check a UX design agency.
It has its own website (not just a Behance/Dribbble/Wix page) and a verifiable physical address, usually visible via a Google Business Profile with photos and reviews.
A single freelancer or a couple of colleagues presenting themselves as a team (‘we’), without the structure of a real agency.
A middleman who claims to own a studio but secretly outsources your project, taking a large cut and often lacking real expertise.
More staff, space, devices and knowledge means faster, higher-quality delivery, and getting your project sooner lets you start earning sooner.
Yes. Even with many NDA projects, it should show several relevant works on its own site; relying only on an external portfolio is a red flag.
Looking for a real agency with 20+ years of work? Talk to Dorve.
Start a project